13. He boasts a bizarre taste in bagels

Bagels may be a popular foodstuff, but Peters likes his served a certain way. And it is a bit of a horror story for foodie traditionalists. “I actually put peanut butter on my bagel. I really like peanut butter and I like to ruin the bagel,” he proudly told respondents in a Yahoo Q&A in 2013. “You know what’s even crazier that I do sometimes? I do cinnamon raisin bagels with peanut butter. It is really, really out there. People say, ‘Evan, don’t do it! Don’t put that peanut butter on that bagel.’ And I do it anyway.”