40 Behind-The-Scenes Secrets About The Brady Bunch That The Show’s Producers Kept Firmly Under Wraps

Image: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

ABC sitcom The Brady Bunch was one of the defining family-friendly TV shows of the early 1970s. But behind its feel-good plots and wholesome, clean-cut characters, the comedy hid a whole host of dark and unusual secrets. Here’s a look at 40 of the juiciest – involving everything from hook-ups and hair problems to casting choices and counseling sessions.

Image: Paramount Television/Courtesy of Getty Images

40. The original Tiger was run over

Ever wondered why Tiger rarely shows up past the midway point of The Brady Bunch’s first season? Well, tragically, the real pooch was knocked down by a car during the show’s early filming. And while the dog’s trainer tried to replace him with a lookalike he picked up at a nearby pound, unsurprisingly the substitute wasn’t able to follow commands in quite the same way as the original canine actor. Producers eventually decided that it wasn’t worth the hassle to retrain the animal, then, and only featured Tiger on screen when absolutely necessary.

Image: via IMDb

39. Jan and Peter were once busted by the police

With so many adolescent hormones flying around on set, it was perhaps inevitable that several of The Brady Bunch’s stars would hook up in real life. Eve Plumb and Christopher Knight – a.k.a. Jan and Peter – were one such pairing. And, scandalously, the on-screen siblings were once caught by the authorities while making out in Knight’s vehicle.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Michael Ochs Archive/Getty Images

38. Mike Lookinland became an alcoholic

Sadly, the youngest member of The Brady Bunch found it difficult to cope with the pressures of childhood fame, and in adulthood he turned to the bottle for comfort. But Mike Lookinland finally got clean before it was too late. He told Oprah Winfrey, “When it became clear that the choice wasn’t between sobering up or drinking, but the choice was actually between living or dying, then it became a simple choice for me.”

Image: via IMDb

37. Barry Williams once went on a date with his on-screen mom

ADVERTISEMENT

In his 1992 autobiography, Barry Williams admitted that as a teen, he had become infatuated with his on-screen mom. He even managed to persuade Florence Henderson – who was 20 years his senior – to go out to dinner with him. Williams explained in his book, “When those little things called hormones start kicking in, you get excited by even inanimate objects. It wasn’t that I sought to bed [Henderson]. I just wanted to spend time with her.”

Image: via IMDb

36. Susan Olsen was forced to dye her hair

During her stint as Cindy, Susan Olsen was made to repeatedly bleach her hair. Why? Well, it was simply to maintain the distinct aesthetic of the Brady kids, as all three boys had to be dark-haired and all three girls had to be blonde. After having been subjected to such treatment since the age of eight, however, Olsen eventually started to lose her hair in large clumps.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

35. Maureen McCormick was once a shoplifter

ADVERTISEMENT

According to one of her on-screen sisters, Maureen McCormick – a.k.a. Marcia – was very much a teenage troublemaker. Yes, Olsen has claimed that her former co-star would often shoplift as a means of passing the time between filming scenes. Rather sneakily, the actress would also allegedly point the finger at the unsuspecting friend she had brought along if she ever got caught in the act.

Image: Tony Korody/Sygma/Sygma via Getty Images

34. Christopher Knight felt exploited by his mom

Knight once told Oprah that he felt betrayed by how his mother had thrust him into the spotlight at such a young age. The actor – who played Peter Brady in the sitcom – said, “I [was] feeling totally prostituted at that point by my mom. I think in a way, I totally was. And by her own admission it was [prostitution of a sort], [but] she was sorry about it.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

33. Ann B. Davis passed away in a freak accident

ADVERTISEMENT

In 2014 one of The Brady Bunch’s most beloved cast members lost her life in a tragic accident. Ann B. Davis – who portrayed family housekeeper Alice – suffered a subdural hematoma following a fall in which her head struck a bathtub. The 88-year-old – who picked up multiple Emmy nominations during her career – sadly failed to regain consciousness after the incident.

Image: via IMDb

32. McCormick and Williams hooked up

Williams and McCormick may have played siblings on screen, but that didn’t stop them from getting hot and heavy away from the cameras. Yes, apparently the pair first hooked up on a moonlit beach walk when The Brady Bunch went to Hawaii. McCormick later revealed in her memoir, “It was our first kiss, and it was long, passionate and deep.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

31. Cindy’s lisp was real

ADVERTISEMENT

If you thought that Cindy’s lisp was fabricated just to make the character more endearing, think again, as the actress who portrayed the youngest Brady did indeed have a very real speech impediment. In fact, Olsen regularly saw a therapist for the problem up until her late teens, after which she decided to treat it with a surgical procedure.

Image: via IMDb

30. Florence Henderson wasn’t the first choice to play Carol Brady

It’s hard to imagine anyone else other than Henderson playing The Brady Bunch’s matriarch Carol. In fact, you may be surprised to hear that Joyce Bulifant was actually first pick for the iconic role owing to her skillful comic timing. But, of course, this wasn’t to be. When the equally hilarious Ann B. Davis was signed up to the sitcom, you see, the producers realized that Carol didn’t need to be so wacky. Ultimately, then, the bigwigs made the character a much more homely figure instead.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

29. Shirley Jones turned down the role of Carol

ADVERTISEMENT

Henderson faced plenty of stiff competition when it came to the role that launched her to fame. Initially, the part of Carol was even offered to – and then turned down by – her best friend Shirley Jones. And as fans likely know, Jones went on to make her name in another classic family-friendly sitcom: The Partridge Family.

Image: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

28. Gene Hackman nearly played Mike

Producer Sherwood Schwartz once revealed that Gene Hackman had been in the running to play The Brady Bunch’s dad Mike. Apparently, the future Hollywood legend only lost out on the role because he simply wasn’t familiar enough to TV audiences at the time. Yet Hackman had the last laugh; just a year after the sitcom premiered, he delivered an ultimately Oscar-winning performance in iconic thriller The French Connection.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Mark Cunningham/MLB Photos via Getty Images

27. Knight couldn’t sing

ADVERTISEMENT

Famously, the Brady family would often burst into song during episodes of the show. But while McCormick, Lookinland and Williams would all belt out tunes in their own voices, tone-deaf Knight had to lip-sync. The youngster later admitted to The Improper Bostonian that he had been left traumatized by the sitcom’s musical moments.

Image: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

26. Several bloopers made it into the final cut

In order to finish episodes of The Brady Bunch on time, editors would often leave in little mistakes that they hoped no viewer would ever notice. But since the sitcom’s syndication, audiences have had plenty of opportunities to spot such bloopers. The errors in question include the family returning home from an errand in a completely different vehicle to the one in which they had left. During one memorable scene, Jan’s haircut also seems to inadvertently change altogether.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Cindy Ord/Getty Images for SiriusXM

25. The show wasn’t as big as you may think

ADVERTISEMENT

Given The Brady Bunch’s sizeable impact upon popular culture, you may assume that the show consistently topped the TV ratings back in the day. But that’s not the case; in fact, the sitcom failed to enter Nielsen’s Top 30 even once during its five-season run. It seems that syndication was the key, then, to making The Brady Bunch iconic.

Image: via IMDb

24. McCormick really did get hit by a football

While filming one particular episode, McCormick learned that sometimes you have to suffer for your art. In “The Subject Was Noses,” Marcia was supposed to get hit by a football thrown by her brother Peter. Instead of using camera trickery or stunt doubles, though, producer Schwartz decided that the best course of action was to fling the pigskin at McCormick’s nose for real.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

23. Carol was supposed to be divorced

ADVERTISEMENT

Before joining Carol and her girls, Mike Brady had of course been married and then sadly widowed. But what about the matriarch herself? Well, although Schwartz had originally intended for Carol to be a divorcée, this would have broken one of primetime TV’s main taboos in the late 1960s. So, the show decided to avoid the subject altogether. Later, Henderson jokingly claimed that her character had actually murdered her first spouse.

Image: Richard Creamer/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

22. The Brady bathroom had no toilet

Seeing a porcelain toilet bowl on screen was a strict no-no when The Brady Bunch first aired. This explains, then, why you never see a john in the bathroom that all of the six kids share. And while the show could have given viewers a glimpse of the tank section – as this wasn’t prohibited – producers decided to do without altogether to make filming easier.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Bettmann/Getty Images

21. There was very nearly a spin-off

ADVERTISEMENT

Fans may remember an episode of The Brady Bunch’s fifth season that saw neighbors Kathy and Ken Kelly and their three adopted kids take center stage. And, initially, this new family on the block – who included the real-life sibling of Mike Lookinland – were once lined up to star in their very own sitcom after The Brady Bunch came to an end. Sadly, though, Kelly’s Kids never actually made it to air.

Image: via IMDb

20. Reed was deliberately written out of the final episode

Robert Reed – a.k.a. Mike – repeatedly fought on set with Schwartz over The Brady Bunch’s scripts. And as it turns out, the actor was so unhappy about the show’s last ever episode that he issued an ultimatum: change it, or he would refuse to show up for filming. Then, when Schwartz simply called his bluff, Reed was as good as his word – explaining exactly why the man of the house doesn’t appear in the series finale.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

19. Henderson liked a dirty joke

ADVERTISEMENT

Henderson may have played a butter-wouldn’t-melt mother on screen, but behind the scenes she was renowned for having a risqué sense of humor. And yet the actress kept up the pretense any time she was approached by a fan. Schwartz’s son Lloyd once told Variety, “Whenever anybody came up to [Henderson] to say anything about the show, she was as warm as could be. I saw it a million times.”

Image: via IMDb

18. Reed stayed in the closet for most of his life

Although many of The Brady Bunch’s cast and crew were aware that Reed was gay, the actor decided to keep his sexuality a secret from the public for most of his life. And Henderson believes that her co-star would have been much happier had he come out of the closet earlier. She told ABC News, “I think had Bob not been forced to live this double life… it would have dissipated a lot of that anger and frustration.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Bettmann/Getty Images

17. Henderson wanted Carol to work

ADVERTISEMENT

Carol may be one of TV’s quintessential housewives, but things could have been very different if Henderson had been given her way. Inspired by her own experience as a working mother, the actress pleaded with the show’s scriptwriters to give Carol another purpose in life; ultimately, though, the team refused to budge.

Image: Archive Photos/Getty Images

16. Reed believed that TV was beneath him

According to Schwartz, Reed thought that television was too tawdry for a man of his talents. The Brady Bunch’s producer and creator once told ABC, “[Reed] wound up on a show that he didn’t want to do in the first place, and it became more and more difficult for him.” And the Mike Brady star certainly had the skillset to do more, as he had trained as a Shakespearean actor for two years before landing his famous role.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: YouTube/Mark Lu

15. The Bradys once had a cat

ADVERTISEMENT

We wouldn’t blame you for not trusting the Bradys to look after your pet. After all, Tiger the dog wasn’t the only animal to go missing early on in the show’s run. In the pilot episode of the series, the family can be seen petting a cat by the name of Fluffy; following that moment, though, the cute feline was never seen or heard of ever again.

Image: via IMDb

14. The show’s creator drew upon his own kids’ life experiences

The Brady Bunch’s creator didn’t look too far for inspiration for the hit show. Often, you see, Schwartz would draw upon his own kids’ experiences for storylines – something with which his daughter Hope wasn’t particularly enamored. She told MeTV, “I was in a unique position regarding the show, and I was going through my own teenage girl angst at the time… When things I considered private showed up on the screen, I wasn’t always happy about it.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

13. McCormick once joked about an affair with Plumb

ADVERTISEMENT

In her 2007 memoir Here’s the Story: Surviving Marcia Brady and Finding My True Voice, McCormick joked about having had an affair with Plumb. Her on-screen sister didn’t see the funny side, however, and so the actress was forced to apologize in an interview with Digital Spy. McCormick said of the incident, “I made the crack to be funny – and for shock value. I’m sorry if [Plumb] took offense.”

Image: via IMDb

12. McCormick struggled with anxiety

After leaving The Brady Bunch behind, McCormick experienced her fair share of personal problems. But life wasn’t completely rosy when she was filming the hit sitcom, either. In her autobiography, the actress wrote, “As a teenager, I had no idea that few people are everything they present to the outside world. Yet there I was, hiding the reality of my life behind the unreal perfection of Marcia Brady. No one suspected the fear that gnawed at me.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Paul Warner/Getty Images

11. Olsen hated playing Shirley Temple

ADVERTISEMENT

In the episode titled “The Snooperstar,” Cindy is tricked by Marcia into impersonating Shirley Temple as a punishment for scanning through her diary. And Olsen has since admitted that she didn’t appreciate that particular storyline. She told Inquisitr, “That was really embarrassing. It would have been really cute when I was seven, but when I was 12, [I was] going, ‘I feel so stupid.’”

Image: via IMDb

10. McCormick once dated Michael Jackson

While competing in British reality show I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here! in 2015, McCormick claimed that she had once stepped out with a megastar. Yes, after being asked by a fellow campmate whether she liked Michael Jackson, the actress replied, “We used to date. We used to go roller skating in Woodland Hills [in California]. I used to go over to [the Jackson family’s] house all the time.” McCormick added that she and the future King of Pop had both been in their mid-teens back then.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

9. Henderson initially wore a wig

ADVERTISEMENT

Shockingly, Henderson was forced to wear a wig during the filming of the first season of The Brady Bunch. But that wasn’t because the star was losing her locks; instead, her short ’do at the time wasn’t deemed to suit the character of Carol. Naturally, then, a hairpiece was brought in as a solution.

Image: via IMDb

8. Williams injured himself in a surfing stunt

In season four, the Brady family famously travel to Hawaii for a vacation, and it’s there that Greg shows off his skills on the surfboard. Unfortunately, though, this led to a real-life disaster for the man who played the eldest Brady boy. On his own blog, Williams revealed, “I was injured during the filming of the surfing episode in Hawaii. I cut my feet on some coral. You can actually see it when I fall headfirst off of my board.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Archive Photos/Getty Images

7. Henderson once counseled Knight for a VH1 show

ADVERTISEMENT

Back in the mid-2000s, Knight landed his own reality series, entitled My Fair Brady, on VH1. During filming, the actor even graciously invited his former on-screen mom onto the show to help provide some relationship guidance. So, Henderson advised Knight to slow things down with his The Surreal Life co-star Adrianne Curry – words of wisdom that weren’t heeded, as the couple went on to wed just months later.

Image: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

6. The kids were cast in a unique way

Before casting the six Brady kids, Schwartz was originally tasked with overseeing tryouts by 264 different child actors. To help whittle that number down, then, he simply placed an array of toys on his desk. How did this work? Well, any youngsters who were seen being distracted by the toys were given the boot. Schwartz believed, you see, that those kids who stayed focused on the matter in hand had the perfect temperament to work in TV.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

5. The casting of Oliver created tension

ADVERTISEMENT

It’s fair to say that Carol’s nephew Oliver – played by Robbie Rist – wasn’t exactly a fan favorite. And it seems that Rist – who showed up in the sitcom’s final season – was just as unpopular with the rest of the cast, too. On his blog, Williams revealed, “The writers were floundering, and [Rist] introduced a very different type of humor into our show. Also, we had been together a long time, and we didn’t really have time to adjust to a new ‘family member.’”

Image: via IMDb

4. McCormick developed a cocaine addiction

In order to deal with her mental health battles, McCormick turned to illegal drugs – and one substance in particular. In her memoir, she wrote, “I sought refuge in seemingly glamorous cocaine dens above Hollywood. I thought I would find answers there, while in reality I was simply running farther from myself. From there, I spiraled downward on a path of self-destruction that cost me my career and very nearly my life.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: via IMDb

3. Williams was a pothead

ADVERTISEMENT

Greg Brady may have been a goody-two-shoes, but the actor who played him was anything but. In his early teens, Williams started smoking pot; for one particular episode of The Brady Bunch, he even turned up on set stoned. Take a closer look at “Law and Disorder,” and you may notice that the squeaky-clean Greg looks suspiciously glassy-eyed.

Image: via IMDb

2. Reed died with HIV

Reed sadly passed away in 1992, with his daughter Karen initially stating that colon cancer was the sole cause. After the star’s death certificate was made public, however, the world learned that he had an underlying condition that had also caused complications. At some point during his life, Reed had been diagnosed with HIV.

ADVERTISEMENT
Image: Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

1. Sixth season storylines were planned

ADVERTISEMENT

Although The Brady Bunch ultimately concluded at the end of its fifth season, there were actually storylines in the offing for a further run. Had more episodes been given the green light, Carol would have likely fallen pregnant with twins, for example. And owing to the ongoing dispute with Reed, the character of Mike would probably have been recast, too.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT